Part 1: Midlife Women and the Voices We Stopped Trusting
In this episode, I share what started as a short article about my own complicated relationship with my voice and grew into something much bigger. After reaching out to my community, fifteen midlife women shared their stories about being talked over, silenced, and told to communicate differently. I also look at what the research says about women's voices in group settings, and why having a seat at the table has never guaranteed having a voice. This is Part 1.
Book your Life Patterns Review here.
Follow me on Substack: https://substack.com/@ericavoell
Get the latest email newsletter: https://ericavoell.com/newsletter
Connect with me: erica[at]ericavoell[dot]com
Follow me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ericavoell.coaching/
Transcript
Welcome to the Unfolding Podcast, a space where we explore what
2
:it looks like to really trust yourself,
say no without guilt, and live your
3
:life like it actually belongs to you.
4
:I am Erica Voell, a Decision Mentor
and Inner-Trust Guide, and I help
5
:women in midlife untangle from the
life patterns of shape-shifting
6
:and keeping everyone else happy.
7
:Claim how they are uniquely
designed to make decisions.
8
:Understand their unique strengths using
human design as a lens, we clear the
9
:noise of conditioning so their no feels
powerful and their yes feels true, and
10
:they can move forward without self-doubt.
11
:Guilt and pressure to prove anything.
12
:On this show, we have honest conversations
about self-trust, boundaries, energy
13
:and identity, especially for women
in midlife who are done living by the
14
:shoulds and second guessing themselves.
15
:If you've taken every personality
test, followed the recommended path,
16
:and still feel like you can't shake
that feeling that you've been spending
17
:your whole life trying to fit in.
18
:When all you really wanted was to
belong, you are in the right place.
19
:You'll hear stories, insights,
and tools rooted in human
20
:design, coaching, and real life.
21
:Not to tell you what to do, like
another self-help book, but to help you
22
:really hear yourself so you can stop
overthinking and start making decisions
23
:that feel grounded, clear, and true.
24
:A friend said something to me over
breakfast recently that stopped
25
:me and I had to write it down.
26
:She said the hardest thing is managing my
rage about not being heard and believed.
27
:Whew.
28
:Midlife women are speaking and
because they have been dismissed or
29
:told to speak a certain way to be
more masculine or to be taken more
30
:seriously, they don't feel heard and
even I have felt this way and it is.
31
:I mean, is it any wonder the
messages we all get are about being
32
:different from who we already are?
33
:After I wrote an article about losing
my voice while being sick, I suddenly
34
:had a bunch of ads on Instagram and
YouTube pop up about how to sound more
35
:confident and speak more eloquently.
36
:And while they appear well intentioned,
they make me grit my teeth.
37
:Every time I see them, they
are still popping up because
38
:they all sound so masculine.
39
:One was from a brand coaching women in
business on how to sound more articulate.
40
:Instead of saying to be honest, saying
something more like, here are the facts,
41
:or instead of, I feel to say the best
course of action is, and definitely don't
42
:say absolutely amazing and saying, I
recommend instead of, I think we should.
43
:One ad that came up recently was a man
speaking to a woman who was clearly
44
:not in midlife or near perimenopause.
45
:He was telling her that with his
training, she'll never forget her words.
46
:And as many of us know, forgetting
our words is a symptom of
47
:midlife and perimenopause,
and we don't exactly love it.
48
:It's not like we try to do
it, but seriously, what a dig.
49
:Never forget your words.
50
:The more eloquently you speak, the
more acceptable you'll become to
51
:the corporate white male crowd.
52
:But those ways of communicating
completely dismiss what women see.
53
:What they notice, what their intuition
is telling them, and it tries to put us
54
:back into these masculine stereotypes
and expectations of what's acceptable
55
:to a specific part of the population.
56
:Back to when women wore power suits to
even try to have a seat at the table.
57
:And yet here we are still
having these conversations.
58
:This episode, which is also a
subset article, started small.
59
:It was going to be my story about my
relationship with my own voice, but after
60
:a conversation with Lana Jean Telles,
I knew this episode needed to include
61
:more voices than my own, and I was
blown away by the response I received.
62
:I put out a call to three different
communities that I'm part of,
63
:my SUBSTACK readers, fellow
coaches, and former clients.
64
:And I wanna be clear that the
women who share their stories
65
:here are not a research sample.
66
:This would not pass the muster
of, you know, a university study.
67
:What I have received are 15
women who identify as being in
68
:midlife, and they responded.
69
:I was not looking for data.
70
:What I found was something
that I did not expect.
71
:Thread after thread of similar stories
told from different voices, from women
72
:ranging from their mid thirties to their
early sixties, from different parts of the
73
:world with different backgrounds and work.
74
:But there was a similar message that was
absorbed early and so completely that most
75
:of us actually stopped questioning where
it came from, what started as one short
76
:episode and article has grown into two
parts, and I feel a deep responsibility
77
:to share an honor what these women trusted
me with, and I don't take that lightly.
78
:So this is part one and part
two will be published next week.
79
:As I said this episode actually started
a few months ago after a conversation
80
:I had with someone who was planning to
host a workshop on the communication
81
:center in Human Design, and I said I
was really hesitant to share it with
82
:my community, but I wasn't sure why.
83
:It was a part of human design that I
was so unsure of, and as I personally
84
:started to dig into the story behind why
I was so unsure, I had a realization.
85
:I have an undefined throat center,
and I don't have a consistent
86
:way of expressing myself.
87
:I've always struggled with that old story
of I don't have anything important to say,
88
:and I talk about that in an episode that
I published in early March, and that story
89
:was keeping me from leaning into sharing
this powerful part of human design.
90
:And then about a month later, I
was watching a class with Charlotte
91
:Webb, who is actually one of the
women in this article and episode.
92
:And I felt this energetic nudge
that this is what I needed to share.
93
:And this episode and an upcoming
workshop for my paid Substack
94
:subscribers have come from that nudge.
95
:But there was something deeper that
I felt like I needed to explore,
96
:and then a conversation with some
friends brought this back up for
97
:me, and I began to explore why
do women not trust their voice?
98
:There are a whole host of reasons
and the stories of the women
99
:who shared their stories this
episode touch on several of them.
100
:From the messages we received growing
up to the experiences we have in
101
:the workplace, and a culture that
many times labels women's voices as
102
:not as important, or even judging
the sound of our own voices.
103
:All you have to do is Google women
trusting their voice, and you
104
:get a wide range of results from
articles to voice coaches and the
105
:voice coaches are not for singing.
106
:And as I explored more,
it struck something in me.
107
:Why was I so hesitant to share this
workshop, but not one that's as complex as
108
:the fears within our human design chart?
109
:And it came down to my
complicated relationship with
110
:my own voice and communication.
111
:When I was a kid, I did not
like the sound of my voice.
112
:I was afraid I sounded like a boy when I
really wanted people to see me as a girl.
113
:I was constantly mistaken
for a boy because I had this
114
:flat Dorothy Hamel haircut.
115
:Hers curled under beautifully.
116
:Mine did not, no matter
how much my mom curled it.
117
:It would look great when I left
the house, but by the time I got
118
:to school, it was a flat bowl cut.
119
:And then as I got older, I really
started to not like my voice.
120
:My singing voice was too whispery.
121
:And I sang with my grandma all the
time who had a beautiful singing voice.
122
:And in middle school, I didn't
qualify for the special choir.
123
:As an adult, I started to believe that
my own voice was grating and harsh,
124
:and my view of the sound of my voice
completely changed when I took a
125
:storytelling class in library school.
126
:I was in my early thirties, and I
had a professor who told me in my
127
:feedback session to be proud of my
voice because it was crisp and clear.
128
:He could see that I was so unsure of
myself when we performed in class.
129
:And from then on I had this
completely different perspective
130
:on the sound of my voice.
131
:And when I was a librarian,
I would visit schools.
132
:I would always do a bit of a double take
when I would first hear my voice on the
133
:speakers when I would use the microphone,
and then a crazy thing started to happen.
134
:I really started to enjoy hearing
my voice over the speakers, and it
135
:felt weird to say that when so many
people talk about how they don't
136
:like the sound of their voices.
137
:I almost didn't.
138
:I didn't wanna tell people that out loud.
139
:Too much because I thought it sounded
egotistical, but what liking the
140
:sound of my voice did not change was
my confidence in what I had to say
141
:when I was speaking about a program
or books, and no one else was there
142
:that it could judge what I was saying,
143
:I was fine.
144
:But when it came time to talk
about something that someone
145
:else might know more about, then
those fears came up super strong.
146
:And as I began to read and to listen
to the stories of the 15 women who
147
:share their stories in this article.
148
:And podcast episode, I noticed that
each woman had a distinct relationship
149
:with the sound of her own voice.
150
:It was fascinating that almost every
woman had a specific moment when
151
:she heard herself from the outside,
either on a recording, a radio ad, a
152
:cassette player, or editing a podcast.
153
:The voice she knew from the
inside did not match what she
154
:heard when she was played back.
155
:But it wasn't just the strangeness
of hearing themselves recorded.
156
:For many of these women, what they
heard played back, had already
157
:been judged by someone else first.
158
:Of the 15 women I spoke to, nearly
all of them, described some version
159
:of discomfort or disconnection
with the sound of their own voice.
160
:For most, it wasn't a single moment.
161
:It was like this slow accumulation
of other people's reactions that
162
:shaped how they heard themselves.
163
:In high school psychology class, Jen
read that high voices were associated
164
:with perceived low intelligence.
165
:That low voices belonged to smart,
confident, and commanding women.
166
:She immediately started
working on lowering her voice.
167
:She wanted to be taken seriously.
168
:Quote, as I got older, I don't think
that ever went away, she said, but as I
169
:matured, I also desperately wanted the
content of what I said to have the same
170
:impact, and that cost me, I think I have
cared too much what people think of me.
171
:Instead of being free to
learn and gain knowledge.
172
:I was scared to say
something that wasn't right.
173
:End quote.
174
:Every time Linda called a friend's
house as a kid, the father would
175
:pick up and announce there's
a boy on the phone for you.
176
:And when she moved to Hawaii as
a teenager, the first thing a boy
177
:she was introduced to asked was,
what was wrong with her voice?
178
:As a young adult, men would suggest
that she be a phone sex operator.
179
:She spent years wishing that her
voice were higher and more feminine.
180
:She said she likes her voice now,
but it took a long time to get there.
181
:And when Charlotte thought about
liking the sound of her voice,
182
:she thought about what that phrase
meant when used about a woman.
183
:Arrogant.
184
:Self-centered.
185
:Attention seeking.
186
:Superior.
187
:She used to cringe at her own voice
rather than risk being seen that way.
188
:. Getting used to her own voice
is still a work in progress.
189
:For Danielle, she said a teacher laughed
at her during a show choir audition,
190
:and for years her own voice felt
like nails on the chalkboard to her.
191
:She has been recording guided
meditations to slowly desensitize
192
:herself to the sound of it.
193
:Now people tell her it's soothing,
and what strikes me about all of
194
:these is how early it started.
195
:Most of us formed an opinion about our
own voices before we were old enough to
196
:question where that opinion came from.
197
:And at some point we all
learned to go silent.
198
:I grew up in a family where
everyone talked over everyone else.
199
:Large family gatherings were loud
with multiple conversations happening
200
:across the room all at once.
201
:And my brain, it wanted
to be in all of them.
202
:I didn't wanna fade into the background.
203
:I felt like I needed to
have something to say.
204
:What I didn't realize was that I was
learning to talk to fill the silences.
205
:I was so uncomfortable with quiet that I
thought being a good person meant having
206
:conversations and filling the gaps.
207
:And I'll never forget being
in the car with my mom.
208
:We were on a three hour trip and she said,
how about you stop talking for a while?
209
:I had talked for almost three those three
hours, and at the time I was so hurt.
210
:But now as a mom, I completely get it.
211
:When I was in high school, I
had no problem speaking up.
212
:I usually knew the answer
and I loved to prove it.
213
:It brought that approval that I was
seeking that external validation.
214
:And then in college,
things started to shift.
215
:I will never forget being in a
Western civilization class and
216
:getting into a heated discussion
with a guy over women's rights.
217
:I eventually backed down,
not because I was wrong.
218
:But because I felt I couldn't make a good
enough argument against his certainty.
219
:I felt defeated because once again
the louder white male voice won.
220
:I found myself talking just to be heard.
221
:What I didn't know then.
222
:Was that that silencing and the
overtalking are often the same things, two
223
:different responses to the same message.
224
:You don't have anything important to say.
225
:The women I spoke with found their
own ways to manage that same feeling.
226
:Some learned early that quiet
was simply what was required.
227
:Ellen described it simply.
228
:She learned to stay silent as a kid,
a good girl, and a people pleaser.
229
:Katie learned to go along flexible and
agreeable, not because she was silencing
230
:herself because she didn't yet know.
231
:She could say, I don't want
that, or I don't like that.
232
:Heather shared that she talked too much
as a kid and was told so, but she also
233
:absorbed something quieter from her
mom who was shy in social situations
234
:and would go silent in groups, and
Heather caught herself doing the same
235
:thing, staying quiet when she didn't
feel like she knew enough to speak.
236
:In Danielle's home, her parents
wanted her to be seen and not heard.
237
:Authentic thoughts were not appreciated.
238
:She was to fall in line and her mother
used to use the silent treatment.
239
:She said, we didn't talk.
240
:In my family it was
either yelling or silence.
241
:And as a child, Erica was told to be quiet
and not to speak up, to not take up space.
242
:It wasn't about talking too much.
243
:It was about learning that her voice
wasn't welcome in the first place, and
244
:that conditioning followed her for years.
245
:She became someone who held things
in, who questioned whether what
246
:she had to say even mattered.
247
:She learned to shrink and to second
guess to allow herself to be talked over
248
:because on some level that felt familiar.
249
:I really learned to say silent.
250
:She said, until I became enraged.
251
:And growing up, Lana wasn't
told that she talked too much.
252
:She was told directly and
often that she did not matter.
253
:So she didn't learn to be silent.
254
:She learned to be invisible.
255
:She poured herself into school, into
achieving into the things that she
256
:could control, trying to prove her
worth in the only ways available to her.
257
:And when that didn't work, she
went the other direction entirely
258
:into struggle and self-sabotage.
259
:With periods of depression,
including moments where she
260
:didn't want to be here at all.
261
:Looking back, she could see it was
all the same thing, trying to be
262
:seen, trying to be heard, just in
ways that weren't always healthy.
263
:A 8-year-old, Veronica was visiting
her cousins on a farm, and she
264
:desperately wanted to go into
town with them, but didn't ask.
265
:Her aunt had a way of making her
feel small and she wasn't willing
266
:to give her another opportunity.
267
:She watched her cousins drive away and
she cried so hard that her grandmother
268
:heard her from across the street.
269
:And when her grandmother came
to check on her, she wiped her
270
:face and she said she was fine.
271
:She said, I didn't just
learn to be polite.
272
:I learned it was safer to not
speak at all rather than to
273
:risk being made to feel small.
274
:Several women described a different kind
of silencing, not being told to be quiet,
275
:but being told that they were too much.
276
:Lizzie was told she was too
dramatic, too intense, and too much.
277
:She wasn't told to talk less.
278
:She was told to feel less so that
she got quieter in a different way.
279
:She stopped getting excited.
280
:She filed herself down to fit what
people around her seemed to want.
281
:She said, I didn't know I was
negotiating in order to survive.
282
:I just did it.
283
:Erin was labeled dramatic accused of
blowing things out of proportion and
284
:seeking attention, labels that felt
deeply wrong to her as an introvert
285
:and an empath who only spoke up when
things became truly unattainable.
286
:Talia said she was the one in her
family who spoke up the most, and
287
:she was shunned for it for years.
288
:Treated a certain way, labeled and judged.
289
:Even people she called friends would
admire it and judge it at the same time.
290
:Other women went quiet in
a different way entirely.
291
:Not silenced so much as
turned inward as a kid.
292
:Jen was naturally shy and
introverted, but an astute observer.
293
:She watched and listened to
the chaotic adults around her.
294
:It might've been that I didn't have
the right words to talk about what
295
:I was seeing and feeling She said.
296
:and she said she had a boyfriend
who was verbally abusive.
297
:She said she was gaslit into
believing that she was wrong about
298
:him and his lies, and she said,
that silenced my voice for a bit.
299
:And Charlotte remembered that the
children should be seen and not
300
:heard energy was present in her home.
301
:She wasn't told she talked too much, but
she felt this particular powerlessness.
302
:Of never being able to win an argument
against someone more dominant or
303
:better at rhetoric than she was.
304
:We learn these things so young and we
absorb them so completely, and somehow
305
:we're surprised when they follow us
into adulthood and into the workplace.
306
:. There can be an unwritten pressure
to sound like someone else.
307
:In the workplace, I was rarely afraid to
ask questions, but they always came with a
308
:hesitation, a worry of being misunderstood
or seen as not knowing enough.
309
:I asked questions to help me
understand, to know why and how things
310
:worked, and how decisions were made.
311
:My questions many times were not welcomed.
312
:I saw it constantly at my library job.
313
:I would name something I was observing,
something I was sensing from the room
314
:or from people around me, conversations
I had with other people, but because
315
:I could not back it up with hard
data, it made me less of an authority.
316
:And a lot of times the weird one, and
nearly after a year since I've left
317
:that library job, I've heard from
former coworkers that things I was
318
:picking up on and was pointing out
are now being noticed by managers.
319
:We are taught that to be taken seriously.
320
:We should say things like,
I think instead of, I feel.
321
:That we should state facts rather
than name what we sense that
322
:we should lead with logic and
leave our intuition at the door.
323
:But those ways of communicating completely
dismiss what women see, what we notice,
324
:what our intuition is telling us.
325
:They push us back toward the
version of authority that was
326
:never designed with us in mind.
327
:Those ads I told you about earlier
are still showing up in my feed two
328
:months later to learn to be more
articulate, to be more assertive.
329
:Instead of saying, to be honest,
saying, here are the facts.
330
:Instead of saying, I feel
to say something stronger.
331
:To say I recommend instead
of, I think we should.
332
:Back to when women wore power suits to
try to even have a seat at the table.
333
:The packaging is different.
334
:But the message is clearly the
same, and the women I spoke with
335
:knew this pressure intimately.
336
:It's not a cultural observation.
337
:It's something that has happened to
them in rooms with specific people on
338
:specific days that they still remember.
339
:And for women working in a male
dominated field, they can feel that
340
:their voice is regularly dismissed.
341
:Standing up publicly for
women being dismissed at work.
342
:Kelly went to bat for people she
genuinely cared about, and afterwards
343
:she was pulled aside and asked if
her company knew what she said.
344
:They implied that she
had embarrassed them.
345
:She remembered that internal struggle
of knowing she had done the right
346
:thing while facing a wall of men
calling her the overreactive woman.
347
:She said it was all men, like an old
boys club, being the hysterical woman.
348
:And in the army, Heather spent
years learning to be careful about
349
:how she said things so she wouldn't
be compared to a wife or a mother.
350
:She said quote, men don't have to
tiptoe around in fear of sounding
351
:like a father or a husband.
352
:She hated that.
353
:She thought it wasn't
fair, and she was right.
354
:Veronica shared that during a high
pressure customer cutover at work, she
355
:was overwhelmed and ended up crying.
356
:She said quote, instead of support, a
woman director mocked me and laughed.
357
:I felt completely
blindsided at that moment.
358
:I learned that showing
emotion wasn't safe.
359
:It was something that
could be used against me.
360
:The unspoken message that I was too
sensitive and too emotional, and it
361
:wasn't the first time I had heard that.
362
:End quote.
363
:She became guarded.
364
:Careful and trying not to reveal too much.
365
:For a long time, she said that she carried
that into how she showed up everywhere.
366
:Sometimes these dismissals are subtle
and sometimes they are more overt.
367
:Erica was asked to step
back from a community she'd
368
:been part of for four years.
369
:She was told that the way she showed
up, the way she communicated the
370
:work, she did no longer fit the
direction the group was heading in.
371
:It was framed as a mismatch but what
she recognized was a confirmation she
372
:had outgrown that container, not that
she needed to become small to belong,
373
:she said, but that she was being called
into spaces that could actually hold
374
:the fullness of who she truly was.
375
:Lisa spent years consciously adapting her
communication, her voice, her tone, her
376
:pace based on how she was being received.
377
:She noticed herself raising her
pitch at the end of sentences, making
378
:statements, sound like questions,
and trained herself out of it.
379
:She did what she thought she
needed to do to be heard.
380
:Several women described being told
directly or indirectly that their
381
:way of communicating was a problem.
382
:Ellen and her ex-husband had a
nationally syndicated radio show, and
383
:if he felt she was talking too much,
he would kick her under the table.
384
:She said It undermined my autonomy and
my confidence, and they stopped listening
385
:to my intuition and trusting myself.
386
:Erin was told to hold her tongue at
work, even when others agreed with her.
387
:And Talia was called controlling
simply for sharing how she felt.
388
:And Lana was told that she elaborated
too much, that she needed to get to the
389
:point and that she was too passionate.
390
:The truth is, she said that
passion was always tied to purpose.
391
:And then there is what Jen
named so clearly the game that
392
:none of us agreed to play.
393
:The patriarchal game meant to keep
women from their inner true voices.
394
:She said a game that keeps women
trapped in a loop of looking outside
395
:for validation and changing their voice
to gain what we think we need to get
396
:ahead, or even just to fit in end quote.
397
:And it turns out there's actually
research that agrees with her.
398
:So it's not just you.
399
:Multiple studies have looked
at what actually happens
400
:when women are in the room.
401
:Scholars at BYU and Princeton
studied students at a top accounting
402
:school and found that having a
seat at the table wasn't enough.
403
:Women spoke up less when they
were outnumbered, they were
404
:seen as less authoritative.
405
:And when they did speak.
406
:They were more likely to be
interrupted and less likely to
407
:be heard, and it actually gets
worse as the room gets bigger.
408
:Researchers from Northeastern University
and the Harvard School of Public Health
409
:found that women were most comfortable
in smaller group settings and once a
410
:group grew beyond five people, it was
the men who dominated the conversation.
411
:And even in the moments when women
did speak communication researchers,
412
:Barbara and Gene Eakins found that after.
413
:Analyzing university faculty
meetings that men spoke more often
414
:and for longer without exception.
415
:As they noted, the women's
longest turns were still shorter
416
:than the men's shortest turns.
417
:And having a seat at the table
does not mean having a voice as we
418
:see in boardrooms over and over.
419
:They say, well, we have a woman
in the boardroom, but that is
420
:not giving the women a voice.
421
:So we have multiple reasons that
women don't trust their voice.
422
:The messages start at home.
423
:They follow us into school and
into the workplace and into the
424
:rooms where decisions are made.
425
:And the women I spoke
with carried all of it.
426
:And for some that weight showed up in
ways that they are still reckoning with.
427
:Something in these women refuse
to stay entirely quiet even after
428
:everything they've experienced.
429
:15 women different lives, different
ages, different homes and workplaces on
430
:different continents, and still there is
the same thread running through all of it.
431
:Women who were told in large ways
and small ways that their voice was
432
:either too much or not enough, that
they needed to be quieter, clearer,
433
:more logical, less emotional, or
more like someone else entirely tire.
434
:They learned to go silent
or to talk over the silence,
435
:which is really the same thing.
436
:Both are ways of managing a world
that wasn't sure what to do with them.
437
:If any of this feels familiar, I
want you to know you are not alone.
438
:These 15 women, and I suspect many
of you listening are also have
439
:carrying this for a long time.
440
:And what I've learned and what
several of these women have found is
441
:that there is a way to come back to
your own voice, not by fixing it or
442
:taking a course on how to sound more
confident, but by understanding how you
443
:were actually, you uniquely designed
to communicate in the first place.
444
:And what's amazing is that your
human design can reveal your
445
:unique way of communicating.
446
:In part two of this series, we're
going to explore what shifted for these
447
:women in finding their confidence in
their voice and their communication.
448
:And I'll talk about what their
human designs reveal about why
449
:their voices work the way they do.
450
:But there's something
bigger happening too.
451
:We are in the middle of a major era shift.
452
:One that's moving from structured logical
masculine energy that has shaped the
453
:way we've communicated for the last
400 years towards something that's
454
:more intuitive, more individual, more
aligned with the way many of us were
455
:already designed to express ourselves.
456
:Midlife women are not
behind the curve on this.
457
:Many of us have been living this way
all along, and our time is coming.
458
:That's what Part two is going
to be about, and I will be going
459
:deeper into communication and your
voice by design in a workshop on
460
:April 29th, which is exclusively
for my paid substack subscribers.
461
:I will see you next week for part
two, and if this episode resonated
462
:with you, I would be so grateful
if you would click the plus sign to
463
:subscribe or share it with a friend.
464
:Thanks for joining me.
465
:Be well.